« Suffer the children | Main | I wanted to believe »

June 22, 2018


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Cult profit in concrete:

I’m sympathetic to light rail but I feel like this topic is really complicated and a deeper analysis is necessary.

While the community may support light rail IN THEORY a lot of local folks will probably be displaced by this development. Knowing how the state likes to minimize damage estimates (I’m thinking of the I-10 eminent domain debacle) people may be right to protest the extension—especially if light rail leads to gentrification and displacement (as it inevitably would in a place like South Phoenix). I thought the Glendale yokels were nuts to turn down light rail (they’re probably just too racist to spend good money on brown communities) but at least the vegan storefronts popping up over there are small, local investors—not the corporate behomeths that accompany light rail. The business owners on south central may be best off being left alone. So while they probably are being played by Koch money, is South Phoenix really ours to fight over? I’d love light rail in So. Phx but not at the cost of losing what’s there, and since i don’t live or work there I don’t know why to care. I mean, outside of thumbing to Sal. I’ll admit that’s pretty important.

And besides, Phoenix has to crash and burn before it can rise out of the ashes again. But Hopefully we can get rail transit all over the valley. If we’re lucky even in our lifetime. Just a thought!!

Interestingly lite rail speeds easterly forward in the rather white city of
conservative Mesa.

Nothing new here. Any area south of the river has always been kept "tamped down". The prevailing thought of the so-called "movers and shakers" of Phoenix has always been to pretend that that area did not exist.

Without a Sneltram, Phoenix's light rail is a POS. I rode it once. Amsterdam's system would have cut the nearly life long trip time by 90%.

Face it, the same corrupt politicians and same corrupt businesses benefited, not citizens.


I'd be very interested in specifics. The political elite was opposed to transit, especially LRT. Leaders who supported it took a big chance, although the voters did support it.

"Same corrupt businesses"? Huh? Business has been slow to see LRT's potential. The ruling Real Estate Industrial Complex has always opposed it and seeks to locate businesses in its car-dependent, polluting suburban office "parks."

Start making sense or don't show up.

Say hi to the boys in Wichita.

I think there might be some value in critique of this project if these supposed grassroots opponents of light rail were discussing the potential of the area to gentrify, but that doesn't appear anywhere in their public statements (somebody correct me if I'm wrong). It's disheartening to watch this unfold as the City Council so cavalierly wishes to throw away nearly $600 million of federal funding because one lane in each direction of Central Avenue will be lost in the project's current iteration. Oh the humanity! It's not as if there are bridges to downtown on 7th St and 7th Ave...oh wait.

Phoenix is an amazing city but it could be so much more than an endless horizon of strip malls if the people of Phoenix demanded a better vision for the city and region. But considering how deeply the kookacracy is entrenched - with the physical environment of our sprawling AZ cities built to inhibit the formation of civic spirit - it's open question if Phoenix and enough of Arizona will undergo a paradigm shift to get away from the bleak, polluted, and dreary future the right-wing is building for our state.

Es Verdad

Houston is still building freeways, though technically not "free"ways since they are toll roads. I'm not a fan of the tollways, but that seems to be the way around here for new roads. At least Valley freeways are all still free.

Freeways aren't free. Their costs include climate-change causing greenhouse gas emissions, unhealthy local pollution, inefficient sprawl, damage to center cities and loss of valuable farmland and desert.


Take away the "freeways" and the CAP and you have Phoenix 1966. No hordes of immigrants from the heartland. A viable downtown and livable city.


With all due respect I am pasting this here and on the last blog also.

Trump Adviser Rips Into Stephen Miller: 'He's Waffen-SS'


A couple of things in response.

First, gentrification of South Phoenix is already happening. This is especially true east of 24th street, where new home development prices range from the upper $200k to $600k. Some of the newcomers are happy to live in a diverse neighborhood, while others want to make it another predominantly white suburb.

Second, there is a core of residents who are making it our business to show up at planning committee meetings and council meetings to look out for the community. The light rail issue is already on our radar and we will show up for it.

I think its absurd to dismiss the concerns of South Phoenix residents in 2018 because of a 2015 vote (during which only 19% of south phoenix residents cast a ballot).

If driverless ride-shares and shuttles are the future, why would the city spend millions of dollars erecting obsolete technology from the 19th century in the middle of a central thoroughfare? Next time you are in town, take some time to drive up central from south mountain. Consider the views looking down on the river and downtown and ask yourself if we should spoil a scenic drive and bikeway with 19th Century technology?

Full disclosure, I live in south phoenix three blocks from the new extension.

I have lived in South Phoenix all my life. We don't want or need the light rail. It is not worth the 5 years of construction and it will destroy our small town feel we love down here.

Kate Gallegos reminds me of Marie Antoinette. She does not care what we the people of South Phoenix say or feel. WE DON'T WANT HER TRAIN!!! I will never vote Democrat again!! BLEXIT!!!!!

BLEXIT!!!! Black and Latinos exiting the Democrat party who don't listen to us!!

Please Vote No Light Rail train in August. We need your help to stop the train down her in South Phoenix. We don't want it. Glendale and Scottsdale didn't want it.

The last line in this story called us 'Bastards' we are not Bastards we are life long Southsiders. We don't want or need this LRT. I use the city bus all the time and usually there is only 3 or 4 people on the bus. We don't want the shoplifters, vagrants, and other bad people it will bring down here. We don't want to change the Southside into the Westside. We don't want apartment complexes replacing our family businesses.

South 7st and South 7th Ave are already very busy all day long and in the afternoon it is bumper to bumper. The LRT is ridiculous and disatorous for us. We know now what we didn't now back in 2015 and we don't want the LRT. What South Phoenix needs is a Cemetery. We live here all our lives and our people are buried all over town.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

My Photo

Your email address:

Powered by FeedBlitz