« Greenscam | Main | Sun city »

November 16, 2009


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Roy Elson is almost 80 and, I suspect, not as sharp as he used to be. He spent years abusing alcohol and amphetamines. He had a late-career crash that led him into bizarre entanglements with criminals. That said, he was the son Hayden never had and served the master faithfully.

Elson hoped Barry Goldwater would take a seat on the Space and Aeronautics Committee back in the early 60s. Arizona's geographic position between California and Texas could have paid huge dividends in the aviation industry. But Goldwater was more interested in the Armed Services Committee since he was already planning on running for president.

Elson, like Hayden and even Goldwater, had his own post-triumph regrets about Arizona and the CAP. He grew up in Tucson and remembers the charm and the beauty of the place. He fought hard for Arizona's destiny but that destiny ended up disappointing him. Hayden himself saw water bankrolling a new and different Arizona, one so alien from his early years. He was like a character by Cormac McCarthy or Wallace Stegner who lived by a different code only to see that code shredded by modernity.

It's an amazing story altogether, one where you can both admire the titans of Arizona's history and wish they had not been quite so successful. Elson came to see Arizona's history as an improbable victory against an implacable reality - the desert. There really isn't another place on Earth where millions migrated to such a hostile environment only because technology and geology allowed it. He knew the desert could be tamed only temporarily and that it would eventually overpower us. As much as we can admire these great men, the civilization they fought for is collapsing from its own contradictions.

I agree with soleri except towards the end. Arizona and Phoenix are hardly alone in the migratory patterns of millions into arid environments in the past and present (from the Cradle of Civilization to present large migrations into regions of Spain, Egypt, much of California including L.A. and San Diego, and the Middle East (UAE and poster child Dubai, Riyadh, and Tel Aviv).

Some of the decisions made in the past have certainly paved the way for a sprawling mess in parts of Phoenix. That mess must be contained and not allowed to spread. This is something that the nation must tackle as a whole; from Atlanta to Seattle. The only difference is much of the nation can hide its hideous sprawl underneath trees whereas it is in your face in Phoenix. This was evident during Atlanta's water crisis and that isn't over by any means. This is a bigger problem and a national crisis.

The caption on the photo is wrong. LBJ is in the center, and Carl Hayden is on the right. Green is on the left. Carl Hayden had an office in the library on the ASU campus that bore his name when I was an undergraduate there. I asked the Senator who his favorite Republican was. His answer: Hubert Humphrey. As a college kid, I supposed it might have been because Hoover's reputation as president paved the way for FDR and the New Deal. Later I learned that Hoover and Harry Truman became close friends. Barry Goldwater cried at Carl Hayden's funeral--they were close friends, too. "Complicated" or not, Members of Arizona's delegation back then worked together across the aisle for the good of the state. Different from today.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

My Photo

Your email address:

Powered by FeedBlitz